The Third Eve

Make a Difference

September 30, 2008 · 21 Comments

Recently someone asked me when I was going to start making a difference, or something to that effect. When I write “to that effect,” I mean that what he said had this particular effect on me, whether he intended it or not. We all make our own meanings out of things sometimes, and that day I made this meaning out of what he said:

When will you make a difference?

dali1 by you.

He might have asked me when would I stop goofing around and start making a difference. Or perhaps he asked when I would write a best-seller. Perhaps he wanted to know when I’d write a luminous book that dante3 by you.changes peoples’ lives. Or maybe he wanted to know when I’d be on Oprah.

Or maybe I want to know the answers to these questions. Or maybe I already know that everyone dies. Living under the cloud of a death is a great leveler, and it illustrates how meaningless–from a human perspective–our accomplishments are. But a death sentence does not excuse one from fulfilling one’s potentials, either. Lately I’ve been wondering again about what, exactly, is required? Where is the manifesto with the manifest of the deeds I’m assigned to complete before I can be said to be making a difference?

The catechism of the Catholic Church says that “God puts us in the world to know, to love, and to serve him, and so to come to paradise.” It also says many other good things. In fact, I think that if people actually read the catechism, they would have an entirely different view of the basis of the Catholic Church and perhaps of Christians in general. And they would also see just how difficult, if dali2 by you.not impossible, it is for human beings to make any sort of transcendent difference at all in our dark world.

But this idea about how hard it is to make a difference could be a cop-out, an excuse for failure. On the other hand, it may be the voice of wisdom. The only difference I can make has to do with my own life, if I can manage even that much. I keep an Aldous Huxley quote on my desk. It says, “I wanted to change the world. But I have found that the only thing one can be sure of changing is oneself.”

So, my answer to this question about when I’ll make a difference was that I’m doing what I’m supposed to be doing; but already, by the time I answered his challenge, I was already failing to make a difference. Earlier this year I knew that I knew what I was supposed to be doing. But I’ve become sidetracked and I’m now so far off track that I can hardly see why I was supposed to be doing what I was doing, if I ever knew at all. Today, I don’t know that I knew why. And knowing why one is doing something is part of the mechanics of being motivated to actually do it. Or is it? I forget.

I’m reminded of the Apostle James, and how he wrote that we are all like a man who looks at himself in the mirror and sees his own face. Afterward, he goes away and forgets what he looked like. He becomes a forgetful hearer of the word, and not a doer. This is the life of the spiritual being: we have what we are supposed to do. We see it clearly reflected: there it is! But we turn away, and we become lost because we forget. We wander.

I’ve wandered. I’ve forgotten what this was about. I’ve imagined that my voice and God’s voice are the same. dante4 by you.“I will ascend to the throne of God,” Lucifer said. What a useful story, the bright, angelic being, most beautiful and beloved of all, with his five deadly “I wills” in Isaiah 14. I will ascend, I will raise, I will ascend, I will sit, I will make myself.

I will make myself.

There it is, right there: the will to be the Creator. Not merely a co-creator with God, as if that weren’t enough glory. No, we want to make ourselves into whatever image we want, what we imagine is right and good.

When I turn away from the mirror that reflects true, I forget. I pick up another mirror, maybe a hereditary one, maybe the one of tradition, maybe a cultural mirror, maybe the mirror my Mother or my Father held in front of my face. That mirror is often not a mirror of love and compassion, the only mirror God has. Call Him what you will-the Divine, the Eternal, the Ineffable, the Mysterious, the Lover, Compassion-he has a hundred names. But by whatever name He goes, He is love. It’s that simple. And when love calls, one responds. But how?

I’ve responded by looking away and by forgetting that I don’t make my self. My self already is. She is right dali6 by you.there, down in there somewhere and coming together like so many pieces of cut, faceted glass going into a beautiful stained-glass window. There’s a pattern and a design; but I’m not the one putting it together. I’m cooperating. Cooperating, that is, until I stop cooperating and start doing whatever I think I must do, need to do, or whatever is demanded of me. And then I go off-track because I’m essentially telling that deep inner voice, the one that knows, hears, and speaks only Truth, to take a hike. I’m telling the only spring of pure Wisdom that exists that I know better, and that even though Wisdom said to do thus-and-so, I am going to do this thing instead, because it’s needful and I must do it, there’s no alternative. And day ekes into night and I wake up weeks later and I’m lost.

Our classics book group has just finished reading Dante’s The Divine Comedy. Of all first lines of all time, other than perhaps Genesis, this is my favorite first line in literature. I hope you’ll take a few moments to read this, because it so beautifully expresses not only what actually happens in mid-life, but also what happens whenever we see where we are supposed to be going, and we’re on that straight road, and then suddenly we become lost.

Midway in our life’s journey, I went astray from the straight road
And woke to find myself alone in a dark wood.
How shall I say what wood that was! I never saw so drear,
So rank, so arduous a wilderness!
Its very memory gives a shape to fear.
Death could scarce be more bitter than that place!
But since it came to good, I will recount
All that I found revealed there by God’s grace.
How I came to it I cannot rightly say,
So drugged and loose with sleep had I become
When I first wandered there from the True Way.

dante5 by you.I know that detours are also in the hand of the Divine; but if we have the power to become co-creators and to share divinity, then do we not also have the power of destruction and of absolute evil? I think we do, yes. And if so, then some of the greatest errors we make are those of omission, the ones that begin when we say, “. . . but it was only a small thing,” or “. . . but, I had to do this needful thing,” and “but you don’t understand.”

This is what has happened to me, which by saying I mean to refuse responsibility. Dante was an honest man, for he wrote, “I went astray . . . and woke to find myself alone in a dark wood.”

Allow me to rephrase: I went astray, and woke to find myself alone in a dark wood of mundane things and duties, which is no less frightening to me that waking to find myself in some medieval forest. Alone.

How will I make a difference? The answer is there, along that path called True Way.

map13 by you.

Art: Woodcuts of The Divine Comedy,  Salvadore Dali

Categories: Individuation · Psychology
Tagged: , , ,

21 responses so far ↓

  • helenl // September 30, 2008 at 1:22 PM | Reply

    Hi Eve, You may hate me for saying this, but, despite your high IQ and superior education, you seem really unhappy. Happiness is a choice, we make daily (or even more often than that) and has little to do with self-discovery or changing churches or psychology period. It has to do with deciding to relate to God and the people around us, no matter how many and who they may be. It has to do with saying, I have enough and know enough to be a useful, loving human being. I am the perfect me already, not the one one I’m working so hard to discover. And those who don’t like me can just get over it or leave or jump from a building or whatever people do who have to demonstrate insane dislike for somebody else who’s trying as hard as they are to live a genuine human life. I am happy because I am me. I wish this same happiness for you, but you have to claim it.

  • Eve // September 30, 2008 at 4:11 PM | Reply

    Helen, you’ve had the rare effect of rendering me momentarily speechless. But of course I don’t hate you for suggesting what you did.

    I simply don’t know what to say in response, so I’ll just say that I don’t know what to say in the face of being told I have to claim happiness. What an extraordinary idea. I hope you’ll send me written instructions for how to do that. ;o)

    In the meantime perhaps it will help if I tell you that I didn’t feel unhappy or think unhappy thoughts as I wrote what I did today. It is what it is. I can be a serious person. But I don’t see what I wrote that might give you the idea that I am caught in a state of unhappiness. Rather, I was momentarily lost and found my way back. That’s all.

  • Baron von Rochester // September 30, 2008 at 6:20 PM | Reply

    I think you claim happiness the same way you claim things at the Lost and Found. You know how that is … you drop your favorite scarf, and you’re pretty sure you lost it at the annual crafters’ bazaar, so you go to the community center and ask to look through their Lost and Found box. And you’re not sure whether you’re looking for something you lost, or something they found. Nothing in the box looks right, even though you think you’ll surely know your own lost thing when you see it.

    But it’s not quite how you remember it before you lost it. I don’t know; maybe someone stepped on it or something … it needs washing, and the end is frayed. Maybe you should just leave it there and let someone else find it. But you don’t, and you discover that it still matches your favorite coat, and still keeps you warm … it just isn’t quite how you pictured it. But it doesn’t really matter, you realize, how you remembered it … it does what it was supposed to do; it keeps out the wind, and still gives you a moment’s pleasure. And it’s yours, frayed ends and all.

    Anyway. I think that’s how happiness gets claimed.

    I mean, I don’t know for sure. I’ve never figured out where the Lost and Found is.

  • Irene // September 30, 2008 at 7:51 PM | Reply

    Maybe your friend was saying “when are you going to stop making up excuses – stop thinking so much and just get on with it”? OR… maybe that’s the message I am reading in between your lines because of how I feel that statement relates to me (more likely) !
    Finding that voice of true wisdom – well, making the space inside so one can actually hear it – takes an awful lot of trust, I think. It seems to go against the grain of every ingrained pattern and control issue I have – ha! But I suppose it is the desire to connect that will make the difference, that will redirect us, as often as it takes, perhaps by prayer or meditation.
    You speak of that feeling of once knowing, and then later, not knowing what was so clear before. I know that one so well, especially with my painting, always aspiring to make my work better somehow, moving in a certain way, seeking an inner connection about it, and then suddenly wham! What am I doing? Was this right? Suddenly I am doubting my motivation, what I had tried for, what was it again? This is happening right now – I found a work I did last year, a small one, that I had tucked away, disliking it (I had strong feelings of ’self-sickness’ whilst forcing myself to finish it). There it was before me, and it moved me so much I took it home ( I realised I had abandoned myself yet again!). It moved me so much, I questioned my process – was my choice to shift my method away from realism the right one? I am afraid. What trap have I fallen into now? Did I succumb again to the desire to be fashionable and fit in, or is it my own path? I’m going to have to sit back and wait I suppose, and wait to see what feels right (hard for an impatient person..).

    I love those works by Dali – their softness is so opposite to his paintings. Inspiring.

  • crazymumma // September 30, 2008 at 8:32 PM | Reply

    After I got over the beauty of the art in this post, all of your posts give me such visual pleasure. I then thought, I love going astray! because it allows me to come back. Hopefully richer. Wiser.

  • helenl // September 30, 2008 at 9:31 PM | Reply

    I guess I’m just weird, Eve. My mother taught us from childhood that happiness is a choice. We cannot always choose or circumstances, and we can’t always choose our initial reactions. I may be nutty but not nutty enough to be happy, if one of my sons calls after having an accident. No, that puts me on the floor, because my knees have just given way. But I do not have to worry about what will happen to them or me, after I’ve gotten over the initial emotion. I have rules that I must follow. They are my rules, and I made them for my own good. I just don’t allow myself to do certain things.

    One of the things I don’t allow is worry. I just stop. Especially, lying in bed at night. If I begin to worry, I fall into Jesus’ arms. How can you worry safe in Jesus’ arms? Okay, how do I know what Jesus’ arms look like? Well, I shut my eyes and everything is a lovely charcoal color with tiny, tiny stars that twinkle. At least that’s how it looks in my bedroom with the amount of light that comes through my eyelids. So Jesus’ arms are charcoal in color, and they are soft. So I envision yards and yards of charcoal velvet. Soft, warm and safe, I fall asleep.

    I’m a big believer in choice. I have lots of choices. I can be sad or mad or glad. Once when my husband was angry, a friend said, he has just as much time to get glad as he did to get mad. And it’s true. I can choose to have a good day or “go with the flow.” I can’t always choose what will happen but I can choose my reaction. If I don’t feel like choosing happiness but really want to, I can fake it for a bit, until I come around. I can take deep breaths. I know you know how to do this because you did when you talked to your daughter’s new teacher. You did it for a different reason, but the action’s the same. If you want to be happy, just act happy until you feel happy. Don’t give yourself too many “pouting breaks” but don’t forget to forgive yourself as often as you would anybody else, maybe more often. You’re stuck with you just like I’m stuck with me. Might as well be happy about it.

    Please note: I do not suffer from clinical depression. When my friends do, I try to cut them some slack.

  • Eve // September 30, 2008 at 9:38 PM | Reply

    The irony here is funny. Art imitates life; I write about going astray and behold, what I intend has gone astray.

    Crazymumma, you ain’t so crazy. Thank you for seeing me through my obvious fog.

  • Eve // September 30, 2008 at 10:04 PM | Reply

    Irene, thank you for your comments and for sharing what’s happened to you. Much of what you shared is very familiar to me, even though you’re a real artist and I am currently playing at writing. Or struggling to write (I’m not sure which right now).

    “It moved me so much, I questioned my process – was my choice to shift my method away from realism the right one? I am afraid. What trap have I fallen into now? Did I succumb again to the desire to be fashionable and fit in, or is it my own path? I’m going to have to sit back and wait I suppose, and wait to see what feels right (hard for an impatient person.” This was quite beautiful for its honesty.

    As for Dali and his Divine Comedy works… I read he found the work compelling, as have several other great artists (which may interest you in particular). He completely illustrated Dante’s work, no small task.

    That last illustration above, of the woman in profile: that’s Dali’s Venus. I’m partial to that one, naturally, for she’s a type of Eve. I would love to have a book of all of these.

  • henitsirk // September 30, 2008 at 11:42 PM | Reply

    Oh Eve, I’m sure this will sound trite or pat or some other devastating monosyllabic word, but you have made a difference, in my life at least. You have brought friendship, and wisdom, and love, and beauty, and humor.

    There are “big” achievements, like climbing Everest, publishing a bestseller, or setting a world record. There are “little” achievements like inspiring someone with an offhand comment, sticking up for someone who is being mistreated, or just cooking dinner for umpteen children every day. Don’t forget, there is Spirit in the mundanities … something Lucifer couldn’t quite see.

    That said … I know you feel off track, off the track of your novitiate of praying, reading, and writing. You’ve been feeling overwhelmed and over-busy, and exhausted. Will these external pressures ease soon, or will you need to consciously carve out some space for yourself again?

    I studied Dante (in the original Italian) in college…it’s interesting how different translations are. The first line is:

    Nel mezzo del cammin di nostra vita
    mi ritrovai per una selva oscura
    ché la diritta via era smarrita.

    Which in a more literal translation would be:

    In the middle of our life’s road
    I found myself again in a dark forest
    Because the right way was lost.

    Funny how this version (my own translation) has more of a sense of normalcy — he’s in the dark forest again, and it relates to how we all are: “our life’s road”.

    As for the Dali paintings, you could pursue buying the complete works here: http://www.dante-2000.de/
    with more info in English here: http://www.dante-2000.de/TOCessay.htm.

    I Googled that, because I love you :-)

  • Irene // October 1, 2008 at 2:35 AM | Reply

    Me a real artist? Ha! I’ve been waiting all my life for everyone to find out what a fake I am! (and this, apparently, is a common fear for all creative types..)
    Keep writing Eve, you’ll get there. Its just important to keep doing it, regardless, even when feeling sick in the stomach about it ;)

  • Eve // October 1, 2008 at 10:40 AM | Reply

    Irene, for me, feeling sick in the head is as big a hazard as feeling sick in the stomach! Ha ha!

  • Lee // October 1, 2008 at 10:48 AM | Reply

    Eve, I think that the fact that you feel that you are on a different path may mean that you are not lost per se. Confused perhaps. Sometimes paths are dark and twisted but you will find your way.

    Perhaps your purpose here has changed. Maybe you are not meant to do the task you thought was yours. I know I have read of others who were sure of their path and purpose and in reality it turned out to be so different from what they had originally thought.

  • Eve // October 1, 2008 at 10:57 AM | Reply

    Heni, God bless you. You make me feel all teary eyed! Thank you for finding these resources for me; I’m fascinated. From time to time I’ve followed an artist’s track and learned some wonderful things. For instance, I once had to write a paper on some art work (we were being taught art criticism). I chose Van Gogh’s “Field of Wheat with Crows.” During the process of researching Van Gogh, I ended up buying and reading the volumes of his correspondence between he and his brother, Theo. I came to just love Van Gogh, even though I never much cared for his actual work before.

    I am beginning to feel similarly about Dali. He’s not my exact cup of tea as an artist (although I find certain periods of his work appeal to me more than others). But reading some yesterday about his fascination with The Divine Comedy stunned me. I’m amazed at how the creative mind works, and particularly the genius. These people just followed not their bliss, but their… I don’t know what. Their fascinations? Their obsessions?

    Anyway. You shared the translation from Dante, and this was a real gift, also. “I found myself again in a dark forest” is just so exactly what I needed to read at this time. I hate it when I’ve struggled or am struggling, and am told what I should do or somehow feel kicked when I’m down. I’m already down! I know I’m down! And dammit, if I wanted to get up, I’d GET MYSELF UP! At my age I know all the shoulds. I have lived shoulds most of my life. I’m not doing “shoulds” as much right now; I am plumbing the depths and it’s a sewer, I tell you!

    Well. You get this. And I know others do, too. But I admit that yesterday after I published this post, I very nearly deleted it and all the comments, because I felt I must be a miserable writer who can’t communicate one thing about myself. But I thought better of it. As my friend said to me yesterday, “If I don’t take care of myself, who will?” We are blessed when anyone does a kindness.

    And I’m rambling. But thank you. I thought of you yesterday and wondered what you’d have to say, and then found your comment in my “awaiting moderation” folder (due to all that Italian, no doubt! hah!). Now I’m off ot immerse myself in Dali, thanks to you.

  • Eve // October 1, 2008 at 11:09 AM | Reply

    Lee, you bring up some good and useful points. For one, not confusing confusion with lostness. That’s helpful! I’m not confused, though. But what I have been, which is overwhelmed, has about the same effect. It actually does help to sort it out and to say that this reality has made me feel lost, but I’m not really too lost after all. I can see the path right there [points].

    I know that what you suggest is true, because I actually could see the way and was able to get back on it. After only 24 hours of practice, I am centered.

    As for people getting confused about the way, that’s also true. I’ve been confused myself in the past. But this time I’m not confused about it, or mistaken. I’m pretty sure of that; I think I have only about a 5-10% error probability, based on my current level of perceived wonkiness. But I do think it’s a good reminder for all of us to consider that things might not be as we thought, and we might actually have taken an entirely wrong turn. So our “off trackness” may well be the means of getting us to where we’re going.

  • Alida // October 1, 2008 at 11:42 AM | Reply

    How does that saying go?

    “If at the end of the day (or your life) you’ve made a difference in the life of one child…”

    Yeah, I think that pretty much sums you up. Mundane or not.

    It’s very easy to lose your way, especially faced with repetitive, mundane obligations that seem to go no where in particular. The despair of walking in circles in the woods and having no idea if you’ll ever find you way out. Then of course, there is a sudden recognition, the stream of light that leads us out of darkness.

    I didn’t glean any unhappiness in your post. I actually thought it was very positive and even a happy post. We are whole beings, God sees it, now all we have to do is acknowledge it too.

    Is that right, or did I totally miss the mark?

  • henitsirk // October 1, 2008 at 11:48 AM | Reply

    Are you saying that your commenters didn’t perceive in your post what you meant them to perceive, and thus you were questioning your ability as a writer? Could be that you weren’t clear enough, or…

    I wonder sometimes about blogging and commenting. It’s pretending to be a conversation, but we miss a true interaction where misconceptions can be corrected or discussed easily and immediately. There is so much in face-to-face conversation that helps get our points across that is missing here. And then, often, commenters are speaking their own truths or opinions, regardless of what the post was about! And then comment on the other comments, ad infinitum.

    I was just reading a book about Albrecht Dürer, who was trained as a goldsmith initially. Fascinating how his father expected him to follow the family trade, which was the norm for his time, but yet he was allowed to change over to engraving and painting. And thank goodness! It reminded me of the scene in Amadeus where Salieri’s rather repressive father chokes to death, and Salieri sends up a silent prayer of thanks to heaven.

    I became entranced by his Self Portrait of 1500. He very consciously painted himself in the style of portraits of Jesus of his day — yet this was not hubris, the art historian said, but rather an expression of being in God’s own image, of the incarnation. I also found it to be an extremely sensual image — the fingers in the fur collar, the shining coils of hair, and so on. I’ll have to get a copy for myself!

    This is what I love about art history–learning about the lives of the artists, how their cultures affected their art and vice versa. And I always marvel at how so many of them are seemingly compelled to create. Some were lucky enough to have personal wealth or patronage that allowed them to immerse themselves; others, like van Gogh, seemed to have no choice in the matter but to bow to their compulsion. Whether they are following a True Way or not is another question!

  • lalber // October 2, 2008 at 5:52 PM | Reply

    Gotta be honest, that kind of thing bothers me, when people ask questions like “When are you going to make a difference?”

    Because you know what? We each make a difference just by being alive. All the rest is ego.

  • Eve // October 3, 2008 at 9:06 AM | Reply

    Alida, no, you got it right. What I was trying to convey, I seemed to convey for some and not for others. But, as Heni points out, this is the nature of blogs and commenting. And other types of human communication (or attempts at it), I’ll add.

  • Eve // October 3, 2008 at 9:10 AM | Reply

    Heni, visual artists and musicians have such odds against them that they in particular bear studying, I think. It’s as if only a real creative obsession or calling is enough to keep them going. Lesser characters would simply take up something else.

  • Eve // October 3, 2008 at 9:12 AM | Reply

    Lisa, “we each make a difference just by being alive. All the rest is ego” is an interesting comment. I think it’s true, but also that we find it hard to believe. And so the struggle begins to “make a difference” that satisfies the ego.

    Well put.

  • lalber // October 3, 2008 at 1:37 PM | Reply

    Agreed. We can’t help trying to satisfy our egos — that’s what we get for having gynormous homo sapien brains!

Leave a Comment